My private Italy: Polenta, or how to feed a country

For me, there is a sound that means winter has truly arrived. It is the slow, heavy blub of polenta bubbling in the pot, like a tiny volcano that never quite erupts. Then comes the scent of toasted corn. It fills the kitchen in minutes and clings to your sweater all day. When polenta finally lands on the wooden board, a golden moon steaming in the middle of the table, the conversation stops for a moment. Everyone knows what comes next.
Polenta looks humble: corn flour, water and salt, nothing else. Yet behind that golden slice lie two thousand years of history. So let me tell the story properly, starting long before anyone in Europe had ever seen an ear of corn.
Before corn: the porridge that built an empire
At the beginning, polenta was not yellow at all. The Romans ate puls, a thick porridge of farro, an ancient wheat, boiled with water and salt. It fed farmers, citizens and, above all, the legionaries, who cooked it at camp after the march. The playwright Plautus even made fun of his fellow Romans with a comic word that meant, more or less, “porridge eaters”.
In the Middle Ages, the recipe changed with the seasons and the soil. Peasants boiled whatever the land gave them: millet, barley, spelt, broad beans, chickpeas. In the mountains they used buckwheat, while in the Apennines they ground chestnuts into a sweet, dark flour. Buckwheat polenta was grey, and the great Italian writer Alessandro Manzoni depicts an unforgettable scene of hunger in The Betrothed, when Tonio’s poor family gathers around a small bowl of grey buckwheat polenta, every eye fixed on the bowl.
The grain from the New World
Then came Christopher Columbus. Maize reached Spain from the Americas at the end of the 15th century, and from there it travelled east. By the middle of the 16th century, farmers in Veneto area were already growing it. They planted it above all in the Polesine, the flat, wet land between the Adige and the Po. They called it granoturco, “Turkish grain”. The name had nothing to do with Turkey: in those days, anything exotic was simply “Turkish”.

Landowners loved it at once, and for good reason. Maize yielded far more than wheat, grew quickly and thrived on land that would otherwise lie idle. Between the 17th and 18th centuries, it conquered the whole Po Valley, from Friuli to Piedmont. The old porridges of millet and buckwheat gave way to a new one: bright yellow, filling and cheap. Polenta, as we know it today, was born.
Not everyone welcomed the newcomer. Many doctors and priests looked at the yellow grain with suspicion, and in some valleys people fed it only to animals at first. But hunger is a powerful persuader. After every bad wheat harvest, a few more fields turned gold with maize, and they never turned back.
When peasants ate nothing but polenta
For many peasant families in northern Italy, maize was not one food among many, but almost the only one. The wheat went to the landowner; the farmer kept the corn. Polenta in the morning, polenta at noon, polenta in the evening. On lucky days there was a little cheese, an onion or a few salted sardines.
The story goes that in the poorest homes, a single herring hung on a string above the table. Each family member rubbed a slice of polenta against it, just to borrow its flavour. A legend, perhaps. But it tells you everything about those winters.
This diet had a hidden price. Maize is poor in vitamins, unless cooks treat it with lime, as the peoples of Mexico had always done. Nobody in Europe knew this. The result was pellagra, from pelle agra, “rough skin”. It began with cracked, sunburnt-looking skin. Then came stomach troubles and, finally, madness. By the late 19th century, it struck tens of thousands of country people in the north. The asylums of Veneto and Lombardy filled with its victims. Only better wages and a more varied diet defeated it, in the early 20th century.
Polentoni and terroni: a very Italian rivalry
This history also gave Italy one of its best-known insults. Southerners began to call northerners polentoni, the “big polenta eaters”. The northerners answered with terroni, “people of the soil”, a jab at the peasants of the south. For decades, especially when millions of southern families moved to Turin and Milan to work in the factories, neither word was affectionate.

Today, fortunately, the great migrations are history, and Italians use these words mostly to tease each other. Also because, in the end, southerners can hardly mock polenta: they have always eaten it too. In Abruzzo and in the Ciociaria, south of Rome, they make polenta alla spianatora. Families pour it straight onto a large wooden board in the middle of the table. They top it with sausage and tomato sauce, and everybody eats from the board, fork in hand, slowly working towards the centre. In Calabria and Sicily, frascatula is a soft polenta cooked with wild greens or broccoli. The polentoni, it turns out, are everywhere.
Where polenta is still queen
That said, the true kingdom of polenta lies in the north-east and along the Alps. In Veneto and Friuli it was, quite literally, the daily bread. Here you still find white polenta, made from the old Biancoperla maize, soft and delicate, the perfect partner for fish. In Venice it comes with schie, tiny grey lagoon shrimps, fried until crunchy. In Vicenza it sits next to the city’s famous baccalà alla vicentina, dried cod slowly stewed in milk and olive oil.
Lombardy is the other great stronghold. In Valtellina they make polenta taragna, with buckwheat and maize flour, finished with butter and melting local cheese such as Casera. Bergamo loves polenta so much that it even has a sweet called polenta e osei. It is a dome-shaped cake covered in yellow marzipan and topped with little chocolate birds. Trentino has the speckled flour of Storo, from a reddish local maize. Piedmont and the Aosta Valley prefer polenta concia, rich with fontina or toma and plenty of butter.

Every March, the small village of Monastero Bormida, in the hills of Asti, celebrates its Polentonissimo. A giant polenta cooks in the square in front of the castle. Local tradition traces the festival back to 1573, when the marquis Del Carretto offered food to a group of travelling tinkers. More than four centuries later, the giant pot still comes out every spring.
Cooking polenta at home: patience and a wooden spoon
In the old farmhouses, polenta cooked in the paiolo, a heavy copper pot that hung over the fire on a chain. Copper spreads the heat evenly, and the pot was never washed with soap. Stirring was a job for whoever was nearest, very often a child. Many Italians of a certain age still remember their aching arms. They also remember the reward: the crunchy crust on the bottom of the pot, scraped off and shared like a treat.
Making polenta is simple, but it asks for patience. The classic ratio is about four parts water to one part flour. That means one litre (just over a quart) for 250 grams (about 9 ounces) of coarse bramata flour. Bring the salted water to the boil and pour the flour in slowly, like rain, whisking all the time to avoid lumps. Then lower the heat and stir with a long wooden spoon for forty to fifty minutes. Tradition says always in the same direction, and I would not argue with tradition. But, to be honest, though, many families now use an electric pot that stirs the polenta on its own, so the cook can look after the other dishes.
Polenta is ready when it pulls away from the sides of the pot. Turn it out onto a wooden board and let it rest for a few minutes. Then cut it the old way, with a cotton thread, never with a knife. If you prefer it soft, add more water and serve it in a bowl as polenta morbida. Leftovers are a gift: the next day, slice them and grill or fry them until crisp. Quick-cooking polenta exists, of course, and it is perfectly fine on a busy weeknight. Just don’t tell a grandmother from Bergamo.
The dishes that make polenta shine
On its own, polenta is a blank canvas. Its magic lies in what it carries. In autumn and winter it is the natural partner of slow-cooked meat: beef brasato braised in red wine, rabbit, spezzatino or venison in salmì. With porcini mushrooms it becomes a mountain feast. In Friuli it meets frico, a golden cake of Montasio cheese and potatoes.
Then there is the dish that every Italian family seems to claim as its own: polenta al ragù. A soft mound of polenta goes into a deep plate, and a ladle of meat sauce, simmered for hours with tomato and a splash of wine, runs down its sides. In many homes the ragù is the same one used for Sunday pasta. Nothing goes to waste, either. In Lombardy and Veneto, cooks layer yesterday’s sliced polenta with ragù and cheese, then bake it until bubbling. They call it polenta pasticciata, and it is a kind of country lasagne without the pasta.

In my corner of Lombardy, food lovers like it very simple: polenta e gorgonzola. Pour the polenta hot and soft into a bowl, add a generous spoonful of creamy Gorgonzola dolce and wait a minute. The cheese melts into the corn, and all you need is a glass of red wine. On my autumn tours in the north, this is often the moment when guests stop taking photos and simply eat. Here on Lake Iseo, my own favourite is tinca al forno con polenta, from the fishing village of Clusane. Cooks stuff the tench with breadcrumbs, Grana Padano and parsley, then bake it slowly in oil. Clusane has been famous for this dish since the late 19th century, and every July the village dedicates a whole week to it. In the hills around Brescia, polenta is also the inseparable companion of spiedo bresciano, a spit of mixed meats turned for hours over the fire.

So there it is, our humble golden moon. A porridge that fed the legions, sat on the table of Manzoni’s poor and caused a disease that emptied villages, today arrives on wooden boards in village festivals and starred restaurants alike. Hunger is over, but polenta is still with us. And every time someone cuts it with a cotton thread, a small slice of Italian history lands on your plate, still steaming.
Ciao da Marcello
Read other articles about Food:
My private Italy: In Milan, eat like a “Milanese”
Food and Wine, Italian traditions, Lake Iseo, Veneto